“Recently in the press there has been a lot written about a certain stag that was shot in Devon: The Emperor of Exmoor. Some called his death barbaric, while others see it as just a normal part of life of the countryside and some people are not really bothered.
Since I am involved in game, its management and the promoting of game, I feel a need to comment on what has been said in all camps for many reasons but mainly because:
- I shoot deer
- I eat the venison that I shoot
- I understand the conscience of poor deer management and would hope to be able to explain this to people that do not have an involvement or understanding of the countryside.
- And finally because I am a country person that lives and understands the beauty and cruelty of Mother Nature.
A load of codswallop
I can comment only on what I have read or seen on TV and, as I understand it, this was a very large stag that was quite old. I did hear one report say “that they could only hope that this animal had passed on its genes to future generations.”
What a load of codswallop. Of course it has. If you are a beast that is that old and big, you gain the right to father many offspring. The question is, are the females of the quality that can bear the good stock that produced this animal?
Good deer management
I have no doubt that this animal was alive because of good management and selective culling to keep the strong best stock. This will produce a good, fit breeding animal, that in turn will ensure that these animals will always be there for future generations to see and enjoy.
We should be aware that we have created countless imbalances within our environment. ‘HOW?’ I hear you ask. Well, each species of animal has another which it relies on for food and to keep it in check. Animals will only breed to the amount of food available to them. That is, if there is lots of food, there will be lots of healthy young.
No natural predators
During the Middle Ages, wolves, bears and other predators kept our deer population in check, as well as the few that we humans took. Fast forward to the present and we are producing 100 if not 1000 times more food in our fields then ever before, so the deer breed better than ever. On the surface, this sounds positive, but we have eradicated the wolf, the bear and any other predator that fed on the deer. Add that to that the fact that we now have three species of non-indigenous deer breeding in the UK in the wild as well and we have a population problem.
We humans are the only predator of deer left. We are the ones that can save the species by doing what the predators did years ago by taking the young and the old to make way for the young and the fit. This is not cruel. This is what Mother Nature would do, as we created the problem, we must be responsible.
An argument for culling
Let me give you a scenario that happens every year in the countryside and offers the reason that animals need to be culled.
Farmer Peter has a small acreage of woodland that holds and sustains a herd of 20 fallow deer comfortably. Farmer Peter also has four very large fields near the woodland which he plants with crops every year. The crops grow, the woodland flourish and the deer feed on both. Because of the abundance of food and lack of predators, the deer do well in the breeding season and produce many young. Now our herd of 20 has become 35, which is okay because there is food in the woodland and in the fields.
Along comes the harvest season, and the farmer takes up his now dwindling crops that the deer have been raiding. By the end of the harvest, the only food available to the 35 strong herd is the woodland, which, if you remember, can only sustain 20 animals. The deer do not take turns at eating or the allow the younger animals to eat first - they all try to eat as much as they can and this puts a serious strain on the amount of food available.
Food famine
As winter approaches, the younger and older animals will start to show signs of malnutrition and some will not have the fat reserves they need to sustain themselves throughout the winter. Some will die. Depending on the severity of the winter, the stronger animals will also begin to suffer because the food that would normally be available to them at this time of year would have been consumed by the larger herd and therefore leave a great gap in the availability of food. So not only will the young and old animals suffer, but the health of the stronger breeding stock will also suffer, affecting the numbers of the herd and its ability reproduce the following season.
Why does this happen? There are two factors. Firstly, there is a missing link in the food chain - the predators (wolves and bears) that we removed from our countryside. These animals would have preyed on the deer and kept their numbers in check so that the herd always kept the strong animals that ensured good breeding stock and good blood lines.
Secondly, the farmer has created an unnatural food source with his crops and - like it or not - the deer will feed on this. This abundance of food triggers the animals to breed well, the bucks are fat and strong and the does have all the vitamins and minerals to produce good young and in many case even producing twins. But then once the young are born, the food source is removed and then we have too many deer for the food available.
Man: the last predator
This is where the responsibility of deer management comes down to us, the last predator. If we want generations to come to be able to see deer herds in the wild, we need to manage our herds so that we can harvest a certain number every year for food. This harvest should be a process of selective culling. By this I mean certain young animals that do not show the strong characteristics and formation of good breeding stock need to be shot, older animals that have had a good life and are at the point of being ousted from the herd (if they are an older buck) or breeding females who are coming to the end of their breeding life also need to be removed.
Selective culling is not only about taking out the deer that are on their last legs or the weak youngsters that will not make it to maturity - even though these animals also need to be culled - it’s about doing what the predators and Mother Nature would have done to move animals out of the herd, so that the younger animals can fall into their place within the herd and carry on the strong bloodlines.
Humans created the problem
We humans have created a problem in removing the predators that would feed on and control the deer. Deer are not the only animal breeding in unnatural numbers that need to be controlled by us – think about foxes, rooks, crows, squirrels and magpies. There is a whole host of species that needs man’s intervention to prevent the pressure of over-population from wiping them out.
If the Emperor was indeed shot (and there have still been sightings of him), he was an older animal and while he may have been shot as a trophy, the meat will not be wasted. If, as the reports suggest, it was a mature stag then it may have been part of a selective cull so he was harvested at his peak. He would have passed on his genes and if, as some reports also suggest, he was not shot and is still walking around Devon, then fantastic. But his time will come in the not too distant future to safeguard the future of the herd, and that is the cycle of life.”