Horse & Country TV

Facebook Twitter YouTube Flickr RSS
Login | Sign-up


Not a member? Register here

Television for horse lovers

Sky channel 280

  • Home
  • News
  • Video
    • Today's top videos on H&C

    • Louise Bell works wonders at Windsor
    • Global Champions Tour comes to London
    • Francis Whittington trains with Yogi Breisner
    • H&C Masterclass: Natasha Baker talks tack
    • What causes laminitis?
    • Francis Whittington on equestrian childhoods

    • View all 1479 videos »
  • TV Shows
    • Featured shows on H&C

    • Monty Roberts and Kelly Marks
    • Dean Dibsdall
    • Equitrekking
    • Rudall's Round-Up
    • Carl Hester
    • FEI Sport

    • View more »
      View full TV schedule »
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Advice
  • Galleries
  • Offers
Home » Blog » Cloning horses will lead to dull competitions

Cloning horses will lead to dull competitions

Guest Blogger
By Guest blogger
Posted 1st August 2012, 2:22pm


image of foal
Cloning will create a stagnant, yet talented pool of horses.

Our news article about cloned horses certainly caused some debate. H&C viewer Jack Turnbull got in touch to put across his views - do you agree? Comment below with your thoughts. If you have a subject you'd like to get off your chest for a guest blog post, email news@horseandcountry.tv and we'll publish the best 

Jack writes: "Should cloned horses be allowed to compete? I think not. I don't want to see a world where I watch top level competition and all of the horses are clones.

Part of the appeal and beauty of equestrian competition is the dynamic between horse and rider, and how it evolves and changes, and how riders learn from each horse they ride. If all of the horses were cloned, then this evolution would stop. All horses would just be the same, and we would see the same partnerships over and over, which would become boring to watch for me. 

Ok, the clones are only 98 per cent the same, and there's still environmental factors to consider, but when you compare that to the 50 per cent maternal/paternal genes of conventional breeding, there's a stark difference.

Also, if we lose that 48-50 per cent input from either the mare or stallion, we lose the chance to create a random, unique combination of genes that provides us with the next wonder-horse, and we just settle for what we have now. Reducing the genetic diversity by cloning for competitions would just create a stagnant, yet talented pool of horses.

An application of cloning, in my eyes, would be to keep certain bloodlines going, by cloning prized stallions or broodmares for breeding. But this should still be in the traditional way of coverings, as it will keep the possibility of creating a perfect random combination, which would produce something truly special, rather than settling for what we perceive as special in the present.

Spare a thought for breeders as well, what would happen to them? Clones could push them out of business if it goes mainstream."

Related links: Breeding & Futurity

You might also be interested in…

  • cloned-foal.jpg Cloned horses to compete at top levels It may sound like something from a sci-fi film, but cloned ...
  • Guest Blogger Guest blogger Would you like to write a one-off blog for H&C? Is there ...
  • Painted racehorse in action at Kempton Racing fans shouldn’t have too much trouble spotting Modern ...

Authors

Alice OppenheimerAnna EdwardsChris Orchard
Gemma TattersallGuest bloggerJay Halim
Jenny RudallNatasha BakerNick Scholfield
Sharon HuntSteph CroxfordVictoria Spicer
William Kennedy

Tags

  • Showing
  • Breeding & Futurity
  • Dog
  • Dog advice
  • Other
  • Life
  • Hickstead
  • Special event
  • Dressage
  • Carriage Driving
  • Eventing
  • Fish
  • Show Jumping
  • Fishing advice
  • Food
  • Event
  • Horse advice
  • Natural Horsemanship
  • Rudall's Round-Up
  • Racing

Browse blog archive

  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
  • Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
  • Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
  • Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

On Horse & Country TV

11:00am Polo Masters 2012
11:30am GCT 2013 London Launch
12:00pm Farming Sunday
12:30pm Equitrekking
Click here to see full TV listings

Advertisment(?)

Exclusive products & offers

Buy H&C Videos from HorseHub
DVD Top Marks
DVD Monty's Memories

Newsletter sign-up

Enter your email address below to receive our monthly Horse & Country newsletter

UK events finder

Find equestrian events in your area


Horse & Country tweets

  • Find out why the British team was unable to compete at the first FEI Dressage Nations Cup competition http://t.co/kDuujlhuLq
    54 minutes ago
    Reply Retweet Favourite
  • Advice: My gelding is herding the new mare in the field http://t.co/n8qfaUdIU7
    2 hours ago
    Reply Retweet Favourite
  • Video: Showing producer Louise Bell chats to H&C about her success at this year's Royal Windsor Horse Show http://t.co/eSBsnRInPR
    15 hours ago
    Reply Retweet Favourite
  • What's on H&C tonight? http://t.co/qGpYeRDVT3
    16 hours ago
    Reply Retweet Favourite
  • Advice: "My horse is overbent in canter - how can I improve his outline?" http://t.co/3W9p7AnnIk
    17 hours ago
    Reply Retweet Favourite

Advertisment(?)

Horse & Country TV

About Us  |  Advertising Info  |  Contact Us  |  Help  |  Terms of Service  |  Privacy Policy  |  Cookies  |  Sitemap  |  Feedback

© H&C TV Ltd 2013